Philosophy: Imagine a planet identical to ours except its "water" i…

Question

Did you know? Imagine a planet identical to ours except its "water" is actually a different chemical called XYZ. Hilary Putnam said: even though both worlds use the word "water", it means different things — so meaning does not live inside our heads, it is tied to the world.

Accepted Answer

Imagine a planet identical to ours except its "water" is actually a different chemical called XYZ. Hilary Putnam said: even though both worlds use the word "water", it means different things — so meaning does not live inside our heads, it is tied to the world.

Stel je een planeet voor identiek aan de onze, behalve dat hun "water" eigenlijk een ander stof is met formule XYZ. Hilary Putnam zei: hoewel beide werelden het woord "water" gebruiken, betekent het iets anders — dus betekenis zit niet in ons hoofd, maar is verbonden aan de wereld.

Meer uit Filosofie · More from Philosophy